Home | Admin | Rss


« A Little R & R
McCain’s New Ad »

NY Times Refuses to Publish McCain Editorial Rebutting Obama’s Last Week

The New York Times has refused to publish an op-ed piece by Sen. John McCain which rebuts an op-ed piece written by Barack Obama and published in the Times the previous week.

ABC’s Rick Klein and Sara Just report: This is not the easiest week for John McCain to get equal time in the media - not with so many journalists in the Middle East to report on Barack Obama’s trip there. And the New York Times op-ed page isn’t making it any easier.

As first reported by The Drudge Report, Sen. John McCain, R-AZ, submitted an opinion piece to the New York Times last week and the paper has rejected it.

A week earlier, the paper published an op-ed by Obama, about the Democrat’s plans for troop draw-down in Iraq. A few days later, the McCain campaign submitted a column rebutting the Obama piece.

According to McCain campaign staffers, the Times rejected the McCain piece and asked for a rewrite to respond directly to some of the claims in the Obama piece, and include an outline of the Republican’s timetable for withdrawal of U.S. troops in Iraq and conditions for withdrawal.

According to McCain campaign staffers, the rejection came Friday night from New York Times oped editorial page editor David Shipley via email:

“I’d be very eager to publish the Senator on the oped page. However I’m not going to be able to accept this piece as currently written,” Shipley writes, according to a copy of the message provided to ABC News.

“It would be terrific to have an article from Sen. McCain that mirrors Sen. Obama’s piece. To that end, the article would have to articulate, in concrete terms how Sen. McCain defines victory in Iraq. It would also have to lay out a clear plan for achieving victory — with troop levels, timetables and measures for compelling the Iraqis to cooperate.”

The McCain campaign has refused to rewrite the piece, saying that the Times’ suggestions are tantamount to insisting that he change his position in order to get his opinions published.

“John McCain believes that victory in Iraq must be based on conditions on the ground, not arbitrary timetables. Unlike Barack Obama, that position will not change based on politics or the demands of the New York Times.” said McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds.

The New York Times has not yet responded to requests for comment.

Drudge has published McCain’s piece and I am posting it here:

In January 2007, when General David Petraeus took command in Iraq, he called the situation “hard” but not “hopeless.” Today, 18 months later, violence has fallen by up to 80% to the lowest levels in four years, and Sunni and Shiite terrorists are reeling from a string of defeats. The situation now is full of hope, but considerable hard work remains to consolidate our fragile gains.

Progress has been due primarily to an increase in the number of troops and a change in their strategy. I was an early advocate of the surge at a time when it had few supporters in Washington. Senator Barack Obama was an equally vocal opponent. “I am not persuaded that 20,000 additional troops in Iraq is going to solve the sectarian violence there,” he said on January 10, 2007. “In fact, I think it will do the reverse.”

Now Senator Obama has been forced to acknowledge that “our troops have performed brilliantly in lowering the level of violence.” But he still denies that any political progress has resulted.

Perhaps he is unaware that the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad has recently certified that, as one news article put it, “Iraq has met all but three of 18 original benchmarks set by Congress last year to measure security, political and economic progress.” Even more heartening has been progress that’s not measured by the benchmarks. More than 90,000 Iraqis, many of them Sunnis who once fought against the government, have signed up as Sons of Iraq to fight against the terrorists. Nor do they measure Prime Minister Nouri al Maliki’s new-found willingness to crack down on Shiite extremists in Basra and Sadr City—actions that have done much to dispel suspicions of sectarianism.

The success of the surge has not changed Senator Obama’s determination to pull out all of our combat troops. All that has changed is his rationale. In a New York Times op-ed and a speech this week, he offered his “plan for Iraq” in advance of his first “fact finding” trip to that country in more than three years. It consisted of the same old proposal to pull all of our troops out within 16 months. In 2007 he wanted to withdraw because he thought the war was lost. If we had taken his advice, it would have been. Now he wants to withdraw because he thinks Iraqis no longer need our assistance.

To make this point, he mangles the evidence. He makes it sound as if Prime Minister Maliki has endorsed the Obama timetable, when all he has said is that he would like a plan for the eventual withdrawal of U.S. troops at some unspecified point in the future.

Senator Obama is also misleading on the Iraqi military’s readiness. The Iraqi Army will be equipped and trained by the middle of next year, but this does not, as Senator Obama suggests, mean that they will then be ready to secure their country without a good deal of help. The Iraqi Air Force, for one, still lags behind, and no modern army can operate without air cover. The Iraqis are also still learning how to conduct planning, logistics, command and control, communications, and other complicated functions needed to support frontline troops.

No one favors a permanent U.S. presence, as Senator Obama charges. A partial withdrawal has already occurred with the departure of five “surge” brigades, and more withdrawals can take place as the security situation improves. As we draw down in Iraq, we can beef up our presence on other battlefields, such as Afghanistan, without fear of leaving a failed state behind. I have said that I expect to welcome home most of our troops from Iraq by the end of my first term in office, in 2013.

But I have also said that any draw-downs must be based on a realistic assessment of conditions on the ground, not on an artificial timetable crafted for domestic political reasons. This is the crux of my disagreement with Senator Obama.

Senator Obama has said that he would consult our commanders on the ground and Iraqi leaders, but he did no such thing before releasing his “plan for Iraq.” Perhaps that’s because he doesn’t want to hear what they have to say. During the course of eight visits to Iraq, I have heard many times from our troops what Major General Jeffrey Hammond, commander of coalition forces in Baghdad, recently said: that leaving based on a timetable would be “very dangerous.”

The danger is that extremists supported by Al Qaeda and Iran could stage a comeback, as they have in the past when we’ve had too few troops in Iraq. Senator Obama seems to have learned nothing from recent history. I find it ironic that he is emulating the worst mistake of the Bush administration by waving the “Mission Accomplished” banner prematurely.

I am also dismayed that he never talks about winning the war—only of ending it. But if we don’t win the war, our enemies will. A triumph for the terrorists would be a disaster for us. That is something I will not allow to happen as president. Instead I will continue implementing a proven counterinsurgency strategy not only in Iraq but also in Afghanistan with the goal of creating stable, secure, self-sustaining democratic allies.

Fairness in the media? When all three major network anchors follow Obama on his foreign campaign trip and treat it as though he were already president? Then McCain can’t even publish his thoughts on the Iraq war? Fairness? What is fairness? Only the media know for sure.

Written by ~J~

This entry was posted on Monday, July 21st, 2008 at 2:55 pm and is filed under 2008 campaign, Barack Obama, John McCain, Media Bias, NY Times, Outrage. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.


Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

:) :( :d :"> :(( \:d/ :x 8-| /:) :o :-? :-" :-w ;) [-( :)>- #:-s (~~) **== *-:) o:-) 3:-o :(|) :)) :-?? :-ss <):) <:-p =:) >:d< @};- [-o< ^:)^ #-o $-) %%- %-( (%) (*) (:| 8-> 8-x 8-} :)] :-$ :-& :* :-\ :-< :> :-@ :-b :-j :-l :p :-s :-c :-h :-t :| :o) :@) :^o ;)) ;;) =(( =)) =d> =p~ >-) >:) >:/ >:p @-) b-( b-) |-) l-) o-+ o-> o=> x( [-x ~:> ~o) ~X( =; more »

Comments for this post will be closed on 19 September 2008.




    July 2008
    M T W T F S S
    « Jun   Aug »
     123456
    78910111213
    14151617181920
    21222324252627
    28293031  

    Text too small? Too large?


    Change it here!

    Verse of the Day


    John McCain
    Go to electionprojection.com


    Powered By
    widgetmate.com
    Sponsored By
    Digital Camera



    Freshly Brewed

    Recently Posted

    September 5, 2008

    • A Little Common Decency Goes A Long Way
    • Obama Without the Protection of a Teleprompter
    • McCain's Acceptance Speech


    Recent Comments

  • ~J~: Guss, I’m not speaking for anyone but myself, but if you as a father operated a huge business would you...
  • Guss: David and Sue. Did we hear the same speech? Was there another one given that I missed? I as someone that was...
  • David M: It was a very good speech, appropriate for the place and time. An acceptance speech at the convention is not...
  • ~J~: I did watch the interview and O’Reilly was more interested in asking his panelists how he did after the...
  • Sue: Excellent overview of the Senator’s speech ~J~.=d> Not really much I can add. Loved the closing..I thought...
  • Sue: Piper has become quite a little celebrity in her own right over the past few days. It is wonderful to watch how...
  • cashmere: Comment deleted for content. Insults to families of candidates are not acceptable at this site. (Sue)
  • ~J~: Hi, David, If you want to see pork just drive through the small state of W. Virginia. They are always doing road...
  • David M.: First,thanks for posting this. As J knows, my job requires I work a lot at night and my wife prefers to...
  • ~J~: Good for Megyn Kelly! She does not suffer fools easily. I’ve seen her tell Republican and Democratic...

  • Conservative Reads


    Newspaper Rack

  • Boston Globe
  • Chicago Sun Times
  • Chicago Tribune
  • Jerusalem Post
  • LA Times
  • Minneapolis Star Tribune
  • New York Times
  • San Francisco Chronicle
  • United Press Int'l
  • USA Today
  • World Net Daily
  • Washington Post
  • Washington Times

  • Schratwieser Consulting


    Proud to be Americans






    Pages

  • Comment went to spam?

  • Archives

  • September 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007
  • July 2007
  • June 2007
  • May 2007
  • April 2007
  • March 2007

  • Categories

  • 2008 campaign (163)
  • 9-11 Commission (1)
  • 9/11 (3)
  • Abortion (8)
  • Abraham Lincoln (2)
  • Academia (3)
  • Accountability (2)
  • Adult Temper Tantrums (14)
  • Adventure (2)
  • Advise and Consent (1)
  • Afghanistan (12)
  • Aggravation (1)
  • Aging (1)
  • Ahmadinejad (12)
  • Al Gore (7)
  • Al Qaeda (28)
  • Al Qaeda in Iraq (1)
  • Al-Sadr (1)
  • America (12)
  • American Flag (1)
  • American Red Cross (1)
  • American Unity (2)
  • Animal Cruelty (3)
  • Animals (33)
  • Anti-Semitism (1)
  • Arabs (1)
  • Artists (10)
  • Attorney General (4)
  • Atty. Gen. (9)
  • Australia (1)
  • Bad News (2)
  • Baking (1)
  • Barack Obama (38)
  • Barbara Bush (1)
  • Barbarism (1)
  • Baseball (2)
  • Battle of Gettysburg (1)
  • BDS (3)
  • Beauty (2)
  • Berkeley (1)
  • Best Wishes (2)
  • Bible (5)
  • Big Brother (3)
  • Bill Clinton (3)
  • bin Laden (2)
  • Biological Weapons (1)
  • Bipartisanship (2)
  • Birthday's (1)
  • Bits and Pieces (39)
  • Blackmail (1)
  • Blogging (31)
  • Blogging Friends (66)
  • Blogs (28)
  • Bloomberg (1)
  • Blue and Red States (1)
  • Bobby Jindal (1)
  • Bravery (1)
  • Breaking News (6)
  • Britain (2)
  • British Military (2)
  • Broadcasting (1)
  • Broken Promises (1)
  • Bureaucracy (1)
  • Bush (14)
  • Byrd (2)
  • C.I.A. (8)
  • CAIR (1)
  • Campaign ads (5)
  • campaign advisors (2)
  • Campaign Cash (2)
  • Campaign Contributions (5)
  • Campaign Fatigue (4)
  • campaign finance (7)
  • Campaign Financing Run Amok (5)
  • campaigns (12)
  • Can't Do (3)
  • Candidates' Spouses (2)
  • Care for the aging (1)
  • Celebration (3)
  • Censorship (1)
  • Ceremonies (1)
  • Charity (7)
  • Charles Schultz (1)
  • Chavez (1)
  • Cheating Spouses (1)
  • Child Abuse (7)
  • Children (60)
  • China (8)
  • Chirac (1)
  • Christianity (25)
  • Christmas (20)
  • Cindy Sheehan (3)
  • civility (6)
  • Classless (10)
  • Clinton (10)
  • Clinton's (6)
  • Co-presidency (1)
  • Comedy (4)
  • Comfort (6)
  • Common Courtesy (5)
  • Common Decency (1)
  • Common Sense (2)
  • Compassion (9)
  • Computer Problems (1)
  • Computers (4)
  • Confusion (1)
  • Congratulations (2)
  • Congress (97)
  • Congressional Dictators (2)
  • Congressional Elections (4)
  • Congressional Generals (22)
  • Congressional Hearings (2)
  • Congressional Pork (10)
  • Conservatives (5)
  • Conspiracy Theories (2)
  • Constitution (6)
  • Constitutional Powers of Executive Branch (6)
  • Constitutional Powers of Legislative Branch (7)
  • Consumer protection (3)
  • Contraceptives (1)
  • Conventions Past (1)
  • Corporate America (1)
  • Corporations (1)
  • Corruption (20)
  • Country Music Artists (1)
  • Courage (4)
  • Creation (1)
  • Creationism (1)
  • Crime (4)
  • Culture of Corruption (2)
  • Customer Satisfaction (1)
  • Cute (7)
  • Dan Fowler (1)
  • Dan Rather (1)
  • Dance (3)
  • Death and Dying (16)
  • Death Penalty (2)
  • Debate (7)
  • Declaration of Independence (2)
  • Delegates (3)
  • Democrat Presidential Candidates (35)
  • Democratic Debates (9)
  • Democratic politics (14)
  • Democrats (41)
  • Demographics (1)
  • Dick Cheney (8)
  • Diplomacy (3)
  • Dirty Politics (9)
  • Dirty Tricks (2)
  • Disaster (1)
  • Discovery (1)
  • Discrimination? (2)
  • Disgraceful (46)
  • Disgusting (3)
  • Disloyalty (3)
  • DNC (2)
  • Do the right thing (1)
  • Domestic Oil Recovery (8)
  • Donations (2)
  • Double Standards (11)
  • Drudge Report (1)
  • Drug Abuse (2)
  • Duke Lacrosse Players (1)
  • Earmark reform (2)
  • Earmarks (1)
  • Easter (4)
  • Economy (9)
  • Education (3)
  • Elderly (3)
  • elections (17)
  • Elvis Presley (1)
  • Embryonic Stem Cell Research (2)
  • Employment (2)
  • Endangered (1)
  • Energy Costs (11)
  • Energy Policy (9)
  • Entertainment (26)
  • Entitlements (1)
  • Environment (4)
  • Environmentalists (2)
  • Espionage (1)
  • Ethically Challenged (2)
  • Everlasting Campaign (1)
  • Evolution (1)
  • Executive Branch (3)
  • Executive Privilege (2)
  • Experimental Medicine (1)
  • fabrications (2)
  • Fairness (3)
  • Faith (60)
  • Fake Outrage (6)
  • False Doctrine (1)
  • Family (45)
  • Family and friends (9)
  • Far Left Nut Roots (2)
  • Far Right Nut Roots (1)
  • Farming (1)
  • Fathers (2)
  • Fathers Day (1)
  • FDA (1)
  • Fear Mongering (2)
  • Feingold (1)
  • Filibusters (3)
  • Film (1)
  • Firefighters (1)
  • First Amendment Rights (2)
  • First Lady Laura Bush (2)
  • Fishing Expeditions (1)
  • Fitzgerald (2)
  • Focus Group (1)
  • Food (1)
  • foolishness (5)
  • Football (4)
  • Foreign Policy (1)
  • Forgiveness (5)
  • Former President Carter (4)
  • Former President Clinton (5)
  • Fox News Network (1)
  • France (4)
  • Frank Sinatra (2)
  • Fred Thompson (44)
  • Freedom of Religion (1)
  • Freedom of Speech (5)
  • Freedom's Watch (2)
  • Friends (8)
  • Friendship (2)
  • Fuel Cost (2)
  • Fun (13)
  • Funny (31)
  • Futility (1)
  • Games in Washington (2)
  • Games of Chance (1)
  • Gays (6)
  • Gaza (2)
  • Gen. Petraeus (1)
  • General Petraeus (3)
  • Gitmo (4)
  • Giving Thanks (1)
  • Global (1)
  • Global Incidents (1)
  • Global Warming (16)
  • God (5)
  • Golf (1)
  • Gonzales (7)
  • Good Friday (1)
  • Good News (7)
  • Government Secrecy (2)
  • Grandmothers (4)
  • Grandparents (1)
  • Greed (1)
  • Greenspan (1)
  • Grief (7)
  • Gross (1)
  • Gun Control (3)
  • Guns (2)
  • Haditha (2)
  • Hamas (4)
  • Happy Birthday! (8)
  • Harry Reid (15)
  • Harvey Korman (1)
  • Hastert (3)
  • Hate Crimes (2)
  • Hatred (11)
  • Headlines (14)
  • Health (26)
  • Health Care (18)
  • Heart Warming (19)
  • Heaven (1)
  • Help Our Troops (1)
  • Helping Others (1)
  • Heroes (19)
  • Hezbollah (1)
  • Hillary Clinton (86)
  • History (23)
  • Hockey (1)
  • Holiday greetings (1)
  • Holidays (7)
  • Homeland INsecurity (3)
  • Homeland Security (3)
  • Honesty (2)
  • Hostages (3)
  • House of Representatives (18)
  • How True (3)
  • Howard Dean (1)
  • Hugo Chavez (1)
  • Human Interest Story (9)
  • Humanity (3)
  • Humor (39)
  • Hurricane Gustav (3)
  • Hypocrites (3)
  • Identity Theft (1)
  • Ill-Serving the President (4)
  • Illegal Drugs (1)
  • Illegal Immigration (35)
  • Illness (5)
  • Immigration (8)
  • Independence Day (1)
  • Infanticide (1)
  • Insignificant Former President (2)
  • Inspirational Music (13)
  • Interview (3)
  • Interviews (2)
  • Invasion of Privacy (1)
  • Investigations (13)
  • Iran (21)
  • Iraq (128)
  • Irritation (1)
  • Islam (9)
  • Israel (25)
  • It's the appearance (5)
  • J's Corner (4)
  • J's Inbox (9)
  • Jenna Bush Hager (1)
  • Jeremiah Wright (1)
  • Jerusalem (1)
  • Jesus (28)
  • Jim Henson (1)
  • Jim McKay (1)
  • Jimmy Carter (3)
  • John Adams (1)
  • John Bolton (1)
  • John Edwards (2)
  • John F. Kennedy (1)
  • John Howard (1)
  • John McCain (33)
  • John Rich (1)
  • Jordan (1)
  • Journalism (23)
  • Journalists (9)
  • Judicial Branch (3)
  • Judiciary (4)
  • Judiciary Committee (1)
  • Justice (23)
  • Kindness (13)
  • Kucinich (1)
  • Kurds (1)
  • Laura Bush (2)
  • Leaks (4)
  • Lebanon (2)
  • Legal (68)
  • Legislation (5)
  • Legislative Branch (3)
  • Libby (16)
  • Liberals (5)
  • Lieberman (4)
  • Lies (1)
  • Live Aid Concert (1)
  • Loss Of A Friend (5)
  • Lottery (1)
  • Love (6)
  • Loved Ones (1)
  • Loyalty (6)
  • Madonna (1)
  • Man (1)
  • Mandates (1)
  • Martin Luther King (1)
  • Mary Winkler (1)
  • McCain (9)
  • Medal of Honor Winner (2)
  • Media (41)
  • Media Bias (4)
  • Medical News (5)
  • Medications (1)
  • Mel Blanc (1)
  • Melissa Lawson (1)
  • Memorial Day (5)
  • Memory Lane (1)
  • Michael Totten (3)
  • Michael Yon (44)
  • Mid-East (2)
  • Mike Huckabee (4)
  • Milbloggers (4)
  • Military (46)
  • Military Justice (11)
  • Milking the Government Cow (1)
  • Miracles Do Happen (4)
  • Miscellaneous (3)
  • Mismanagement (1)
  • Mitt Romney (4)
  • Mothers (2)
  • Mothers Day (2)
  • Moveon.org (6)
  • Mr. and/or Mrs. Edwards (12)
  • Muppets (1)
  • Murtha (4)
  • Music (38)
  • Muslims (1)
  • Nancy Pelosi (10)
  • Nano-Weapons (1)
  • National Archives (2)
  • National Security (1)
  • Native Americans (11)
  • Nature (3)
  • net censorship (2)
  • Network Viewership Ratings (1)
  • Nevada Primary (1)
  • New Hampshire (1)
  • News Anchors (1)
  • Newspapers (4)
  • Newt Gingrich (1)
  • Nifong (3)
  • Norman Hsu (4)
  • North Korea (3)
  • NRCC (2)
  • NY Times (14)
  • NYC Crazies (2)
  • Obama (12)
  • Obituaries (3)
  • Obnoxious (4)
  • Odd News (1)
  • Oil (1)
  • Oil Prices (2)
  • Old Age (1)
  • Olympic Games (3)
  • Omega Letter (1)
  • Opinion (13)
  • opinions (1)
  • Origami (1)
  • Orphans (10)
  • Osama Bin Laden (1)
  • Our Government (4)
  • Our Military (34)
  • Outrage (52)
  • Pakistan (5)
  • Palestinians (8)
  • Parenting (1)
  • partisanship (4)
  • Party Registration (2)
  • Patriotism (12)
  • Peace Protesters (1)
  • Peanuts (1)
  • Pelosi (17)
  • Personal (5)
  • Pet Peeves (1)
  • Pets (11)
  • Philosophy (1)
  • Photographs (5)
  • Plame (4)
  • Political Conventions (1)
  • Politicians (16)
  • Politics (66)
  • Polls (17)
  • Pork (4)
  • Poverty (2)
  • Praise and Worship (1)
  • Praise to the Lord (11)
  • Prayer (23)
  • Prayer Request (14)
  • Precious (2)
  • Prejudice (3)
  • President Bush (72)
  • President Clinton (3)
  • President Putin (2)
  • President Reagan (2)
  • President Sarkozy (2)
  • Presidential Campaign Marathons (6)
  • Presidential candidates (39)
  • Presidential Debates (4)
  • Presidential Election (7)
  • Presidents Day (2)